Advice is what we ask for when we already know the answer but wish we didn't. — Erica Jong

Advice is what we ask for when we already know the answer but wish we didn't.

Author: Erica Jong

Insight: We've all done it: asked a friend what they think about a decision we've already basically made. We describe the situation in meticulous detail, laying out all the facts we clearly know well, then ask "so what do you think I should do?" What we're really hoping for is permission to do what we want, or maybe someone to share the blame if it goes wrong. The tricky part is that this impulse isn't weakness or dishonesty exactly—it's human. We know things intellectually but struggle with them emotionally. Staying in a relationship that isn't working, taking a risky job, confronting someone we're angry at—we often understand the logical answer long before we're ready to act on it. Asking for advice buys us time, transfers some responsibility, and lets us test-drive the decision out loud before committing to it. The real usefulness of this quote isn't to make you feel bad for seeking advice. It's an invitation to notice the gap between what you know and what you're willing to do. That gap is where the actual work lives. Next time you find yourself asking for advice, pause and ask yourself: what am I hoping someone else will tell me? Sometimes that answer matters more than any advice they could give.

The gap between knowing and doing

Advice is what we ask for when we already know the answer but wish we didn't.

We've all done it: asked a friend what they think about a decision we've already basically made. We describe the situation in meticulous detail, laying out all the facts we clearly know well, then ask "so what do you think I should do?" What we're really hoping for is permission to do what we want, or maybe someone to share the blame if it goes wrong.

The tricky part is that this impulse isn't weakness or dishonesty exactly—it's human. We know things intellectually but struggle with them emotionally. Staying in a relationship that isn't working, taking a risky job, confronting someone we're angry at—we often understand the logical answer long before we're ready to act on it. Asking for advice buys us time, transfers some responsibility, and lets us test-drive the decision out loud before committing to it.

The real usefulness of this quote isn't to make you feel bad for seeking advice. It's an invitation to notice the gap between what you know and what you're willing to do. That gap is where the actual work lives. Next time you find yourself asking for advice, pause and ask yourself: what am I hoping someone else will tell me? Sometimes that answer matters more than any advice they could give.

AI generated

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment or reply to one.

Sign in

Erica Jong

Erica Jong is an American novelist, poet, and essayist known for her best-selling novel "Fear of Flying," which explores themes of female sexuality and liberation. Throughout her career, she has been a prominent voice in feminist literature, addressing taboo topics with wit and honesty.

Graph

Related