Good singing is learning how to transmit learning musical information with your voice in a way that everybody... — Weyes Blood

Good singing is learning how to transmit learning musical information with your voice in a way that everybody can relate to. But as a woman you just get a lot of criticism because everyone sees you like a raw lump of clay that needs some help.

Author: Weyes Blood

Insight: There's something quietly radical about centering technique and craft in a quote about singing, then immediately naming how that gets sidestepped the moment a woman enters the room. It's the difference between "you're not good enough yet" and "you're not good enough as you are." One invites growth; the other suggests you're fundamentally unfinished. This matters beyond music. Any space where women are expected to master their craft while also accepting constant unsolicited sculpting—whether that's how you look, how you sound, how you present yourself—creates this exhausting double bind. You're supposed to get better at your actual skill while also staying receptive to being remade. The burden isn't just performing well; it's performing well while remaining moldable, grateful for the guidance. The clearest part of Weyes Blood's point is that it's a distraction from what actually matters: Can you communicate something true and moving? Do people feel it? But when half the human population is regularly treated as a work-in-progress rather than a finished artist, that simple question becomes surprisingly difficult to answer honestly. The criticism isn't feedback on the singing. It's noise layered over it.

The difference between critique and reconstruction

Good singing is learning how to transmit learning musical information with your voice in a way that everybody can relate to. But as a woman you just get a lot of criticism because everyone sees you like a raw lump of clay that needs some help.

There's something quietly radical about centering technique and craft in a quote about singing, then immediately naming how that gets sidestepped the moment a woman enters the room. It's the difference between "you're not good enough yet" and "you're not good enough as you are." One invites growth; the other suggests you're fundamentally unfinished.

This matters beyond music. Any space where women are expected to master their craft while also accepting constant unsolicited sculpting—whether that's how you look, how you sound, how you present yourself—creates this exhausting double bind. You're supposed to get better at your actual skill while also staying receptive to being remade. The burden isn't just performing well; it's performing well while remaining moldable, grateful for the guidance.

The clearest part of Weyes Blood's point is that it's a distraction from what actually matters: Can you communicate something true and moving? Do people feel it? But when half the human population is regularly treated as a work-in-progress rather than a finished artist, that simple question becomes surprisingly difficult to answer honestly. The criticism isn't feedback on the singing. It's noise layered over it.

AI generated

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment or reply to one.

Sign in

Weyes Blood

Weyes Blood, born Natalie Mering in 1988, is an American singer-songwriter known for her ethereal sound and introspective lyrics that blend elements of folk, pop, and psychedelia. She gained significant recognition with her albums "Front Row Seat to Earth" and "Titanic Rising," which showcase her haunting vocals and intricate compositions. Mering's music often explores themes of love, loss, and existential reflection, earning her a dedicated following and critical acclaim.

Graph

Related