If having a soul means being able to feel love and loyalty and gratitude, then animals are better off than a l... — James Herriot

If having a soul means being able to feel love and loyalty and gratitude, then animals are better off than a lot of humans.

Author: James Herriot

Insight: We often think of being human as automatically making us superior—we have reason, language, morality. But Herriot's veterinary practice forced him to witness something uncomfortable: animals consistently displayed fierce love, unwavering loyalty, and genuine gratitude in ways many people seem to have trained themselves out of. A dog's joy at your return home isn't performed or conditional. It just is. The real sting in this observation is that we have the capacity for these things but frequently choose not to exercise it. We hold grudges longer than makes sense. We betray people we claim to love over convenience or ego. We take kindness for granted so routinely we barely notice it. Meanwhile, the animals we sometimes dismiss as "just instinct" seem to have figured out something we've complicated into irrelevance. This doesn't mean we should romanticize animals or pretend they experience the world as we do. But it's worth sitting with the possibility that having a highly developed brain doesn't automatically make us better at the things that actually matter—connection, loyalty, appreciation. Sometimes it just gives us more elaborate ways to avoid them.

/Quotes

We've complicated what animals got right

If having a soul means being able to feel love and loyalty and gratitude, then animals are better off than a lot of humans.

James Herriot

We often think of being human as automatically making us superior—we have reason, language, morality. But Herriot's veterinary practice forced him to witness something uncomfortable: animals consistently displayed fierce love, unwavering loyalty, and genuine gratitude in ways many people seem to have trained themselves out of. A dog's joy at your return home isn't performed or conditional. It just is.

The real sting in this observation is that we have the capacity for these things but frequently choose not to exercise it. We hold grudges longer than makes sense. We betray people we claim to love over convenience or ego. We take kindness for granted so routinely we barely notice it. Meanwhile, the animals we sometimes dismiss as "just instinct" seem to have figured out something we've complicated into irrelevance.

This doesn't mean we should romanticize animals or pretend they experience the world as we do. But it's worth sitting with the possibility that having a highly developed brain doesn't automatically make us better at the things that actually matter—connection, loyalty, appreciation. Sometimes it just gives us more elaborate ways to avoid them.

AI generated

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment or reply to one.

Sign in

James Herriot

James Herriot was the pen name of British veterinarian and author Alf Wight, born on October 3, 1916, in Sunderland, England. He is best known for his beloved series of semi-autobiographical books about the experiences of a country vet in the Yorkshire Dales, starting with "All Creatures Great and Small," which has been adapted into multiple television series and films. Herriot's warmth and humor captured the daily life and challenges of veterinary practice in the mid-20th century, making him an iconic figure in both literature and veterinary medicine.

Graph

Related